What is an Inheritance Act claim?
An Inheritance Act claim is a legal claim brought under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 by someone who believes a deceased person’s Will, or the intestacy rules where there is no valid Will, have failed to make reasonable financial provision for them.
The 1975 Act does not allow the court to rewrite a Will simply because a family member or dependant is unhappy with what they have inherited. Instead, the court considers whether the provision made for an eligible claimant is reasonable in light of all the circumstances.
What does reasonable financial provision mean?
What amounts to reasonable financial provision depends on who is making the claim.
For a surviving spouse or civil partner, the court applies a broader test. It considers what financial provision would be reasonable in all the circumstances, whether or not that provision is required for maintenance.
For most other eligible claimants, the focus is usually on what would be reasonable for their maintenance. This means the claimant may need to show that they have genuine financial needs that are not being adequately met by the provision they have received from the estate.
Reasonable provision will therefore look different from one case to another. The court will assess the claimant’s circumstances rather than apply a fixed formula or percentage of the estate.
What factors does the court consider?
When deciding an Inheritance Act claim, the court will consider a range of factors to determine whether reasonable financial provision has been made. These can include:
- the claimant’s current and future financial resources and needs
- the financial resources and needs of any beneficiaries and other claimants
- any obligations and responsibilities the deceased had towards the claimant or other individuals
- the size and nature of the estate
- any physical or mental disability affecting the claimant or a beneficiary
- the standard of living the claimant was accustomed to
- any financial provision the deceased made for the claimant during their lifetime
- the conduct of the parties, where the court considers this relevant
The court will look at the circumstances as a whole, including the financial needs of both the claimant and the beneficiaries. No single factor will necessarily determine the outcome, and the weight given to each consideration will depend on the individual circumstances of the case.
Is an Inheritance Act claim the same as contesting a Will?
No. An Inheritance Act claim is different from a contentious probate dispute about whether a Will is legally valid.
A contentious probate claim may involve issues such as whether the deceased had testamentary capacity, whether there was undue influence, or whether the executor acted according to the Will.
By contrast, a claim under the Inheritance Act can proceed on the basis that the Will is valid. The claimant is instead arguing that the Will, or the intestacy rules, has not made reasonable financial provision for them.
This distinction is important because the evidence, legal arguments and possible remedies can be very different.
What can the court award?
If an Inheritance Act claim succeeds, the court has a range of powers to make financial provision from the deceased’s estate.
Depending on the circumstances, this may include a lump sum payment, ongoing payments, a transfer of property, or other forms of financial support.
In some cases, the court may also order that assets are held on trust for the claimant rather than transferred outright. The form of any court order will depend on what the court considers reasonable and appropriate in the circumstances.
Does making a claim guarantee an inheritance?
No. Being eligible to bring an Act claim does not automatically mean the claim will succeed.
A potential claimant must still show that there is an arguable case that the deceased’s estate has failed to make reasonable financial provision for them.
The strength of the claim will depend on the claimant’s personal and financial circumstances, the size of the estate, the needs of other beneficiaries and the nature of the relationship with the deceased.
This is why early legal advice is valuable. A lawyer will assess whether there is an arguable case, explain the evidence that may be needed and help the claimant understand the likely risks, costs and possible outcomes before court proceedings are started.
How does the Inheritance Act claim procedure work?
Although every dispute is different, an Inheritance Act claim will commonly follow several stages. At Walker Foster, we take a practical and supportive approach, helping clients understand their position from the outset and guiding them through each stage of the process.
1. Assess the claim and gather evidence
The first stage is to establish whether the potential claimant is eligible to bring a claim and whether there is an arguable case.
At Walker Foster, we will review the circumstances of the estate, the terms of the Will where there is one, and the claimant’s relationship with the deceased. We will also consider the claimant’s financial position and the provision, if any, that has been made for them. Evidence may need to be gathered about:
- income and expenditure
- savings, investments and other assets
- housing requirements
- current and future financial needs
- the value and nature of the estate
- the position of other beneficiaries
This allows us to build a clear picture of the claim and advise on the most appropriate way forward.
2. Notify the personal representatives
If there are grounds to pursue the claim, the executors or administrators of the estate will normally need to be informed.
We handle this correspondence on your behalf, setting out the basis of the claim clearly and requesting any information needed to understand the estate and the position of the other parties.
This stage will also help identify the main areas of disagreement and establish whether there is scope to resolve matters without court proceedings.
3. Explore negotiation or mediation
An Inheritance Act claim does not automatically have to go to trial. Wherever appropriate, we will explore whether the dispute can be resolved through negotiation or mediation.
Reaching an agreement gives the parties greater control over the outcome and may avoid some of the cost, time and uncertainty associated with a contested hearing. Depending on the circumstances, a settlement could involve:
- a lump sum payment
- the transfer of property
- an ongoing financial arrangement
- another form of reasonable financial provision
Our role is to help you assess any proposals carefully and understand what they would mean for you before making a decision.
4. Issue court proceedings where necessary
If an agreement cannot be reached, or the relevant time limit means action is needed to protect your position, it may be necessary to issue court proceedings.
Walker Foster can guide you through this process, prepare the necessary documents and represent your interests as the claim progresses. Negotiations can continue even after proceedings have started, and settlement may still be possible before a final hearing.
If the matter does proceed to a hearing, the court will consider the evidence from all parties and decide whether reasonable financial provision should be made from the estate.
Throughout the process, we will keep you informed, explain your options clearly and help you make decisions with a full understanding of the potential risks, costs and next steps.
Who can make an Inheritance Act claim?
Only certain people are entitled to make a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. These include:
- a spouse or civil partner of the deceased;
- a former spouse or former civil partner who has not remarried or entered a new civil partnership, subject to certain restrictions;
- someone who, for the two years immediately before the deceased’s death, lived in the same household as the deceased as if they were married or civil partners;
- children of the deceased, including adult children;
- someone in relation to whom the deceased stood in the role of a parent, which can include step children and others treated as a child of the family; and
- someone who was being maintained, wholly or partly, by the deceased immediately before their death.
Eligibility alone does not establish that an Act claim will succeed. The circumstances of the claimant, their relationship with the deceased and the provision already made for them will all be relevant.
What is the time limit for an Inheritance Act claim?
The time limit is one of the most important aspects of making claims under the 1975 Act.
Generally, an application must be brought within six months from the date on which representation in respect of the estate is first taken out. In practice, this will usually mean the date of the Grant of Probate or Grant of Letters of Administration.
The six month time limit therefore does not normally run from the date the deceased died.
It is also possible to start a claim before a Grant has been issued. If the six month deadline has already passed, the claimant will need the court's permission to proceed. Permission is discretionary and should never be assumed.
The court can consider various factors when dealing with a late Act claim, including the reasons for the delay, whether there is an arguable case and the impact on other beneficiaries. Anyone approaching or beyond the six month period should therefore act quickly and seek expert legal advice.
Are standstill agreements enforceable?
The parties may sometimes agree not to take a limitation point while negotiations continue. However, a standstill agreement does not remove the statutory time limit or replace the need for court permission where proceedings are issued after it has expired.
For that reason, relying on an agreement instead of protecting the six month deadline can carry significant risk.
How long does an Inheritance Act claim take?
There is no fixed timeframe. A straightforward claim that settles through negotiation may conclude comparatively quickly, while complex court proceedings involving several parties, substantial evidence or disputed estate values can take considerably longer.
The key point is that the length of the overall process does not change the initial six month time limit for bringing the claim.
How do you defend an Inheritance Act claim?
Executors and beneficiaries faced with an Act claim should obtain advice as soon as possible.
Defending a claim may involve examining whether the claimant is eligible, considering their evidence of financial need, assessing the deceased’s obligations towards them and identifying the needs of other beneficiaries.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be appropriate to challenge the claim, negotiate a settlement or participate in mediation. Personal representatives should generally remain neutral where appropriate and ensure that the estate is administered properly while the dispute is unresolved.
How much does an Inheritance Act court claim cost?
The costs can vary significantly depending on the complexity of the case and whether it settles or reaches a final hearing. There may be lawyer’s costs, barristers’ fees, expert costs and a fee for issuing the court claim.
HM Courts & Tribunals Service publishes the current civil court fees, which can change. Fees may also apply to a counterclaim; for a money counterclaim, the applicable fee is based on its value.
There is no automatic rule that the deceased's estate will pay everyone’s legal costs, so potential costs and cost risk should be discussed at an early stage.
What is the 28 day rule for inheritance?
The 28 day rule is separate from the six month time limit applying to an Inheritance Act claim.
Where someone dies intestate, their surviving spouse or civil partner generally needs to survive them by 28 days to inherit under the statutory intestacy provisions. If the spouse or civil partner dies within that period, the intestacy rules operate as though they had not survived the deceased.
This should not be confused with the deadline for a claim under the Inheritance Act.