Costs reduced for failure to mediate
Feb 26, 2015
The High Court has penalised a successful defendant for failing to mediate by awarding it only two-thirds of its costs even though it won.
The High Court has penalised a successful defendant for failing to mediate by awarding it only two-thirds of its costs even though it won.

The defendant did agree to a round table meeting or mediation but then changed its mind because it no longer considered mediation to be an appropriate use of resources. It failed to set out its reasoning further in writing.
The defendant had failed without adequate (or adequately articulated) justification to engage in mediation which had a reasonable prospect of success. The court dismissed the defendant’s argument that it thought that the claimants would only accept a financial offer which the defendant was unlikely to make, therefore ADR was not appropriate. The Judge observed that the defendant failed to allocate sufficient time, attention and resources to dealing with ADR (alternative dispute resolution) in parallel to substantive preparation.
You should take any ADR proposal seriously (even if the other side appears inflexible) and always to set out your position clearly in writing, with reasons.
Contact Luca Angarano on 01756 700200 and la@walkerfoster.com for advice.


27 Riddings Road, Ilkley, LS29 9LX
1 High Street, Settle, BD24 9EX
63 Kirkgate, Silsden, Keighley, BD20 0PB
3 High Street, Skipton, BD23 1AA
First Floor, 7 Victoria Avenue, Harrogate, HG1 1EQ
Century House, Northallerton, DL6 2XQ
Many people assume that only someone named in a Will can challenge it. In reality, a person does not always need to be included as a beneficiary to contest a Will. In certain circumstances, someone who has been left out may still have legal standing to bring a claim.
When a person dies, their estate will be administered by a person or persons named as ‘executors’ in their will, or, in cases where they did not leave one, by anyone who has the highest standing to do so (which largely matches the rules of who benefits under a so-called intestacy). These individuals are also called personal representatives (PRs).
When a dispute arises between two parties, it’s not as simple as going straight to court. Before formal legal proceedings can begin, there are pre-action conduct requirements that must be followed.
Many business owners encounter commercial disputes at some stage, as disagreements are a natural part of running a business. In most cases, issues can be addressed and resolved internally through open communication and practical problem-solving.